Which one do you think is better - comments with cards...

Or comments without cards, but with a highlight on-hover...

Please comment with reasons for your choice. Thank you!

  • 207
Comments (3)
  • I am leaning towards comments without cards, as this would add yet another element that needs to be customisable, and would also require extra margins, so when you see comments in, say, a timeline card, which is sitting withing a block, you'd end up with 3 sets of margins on each site, eating up at least 60px of space on mobile. 

    • Just another couple of elements to manage and worry about whether it works for everyone and all device screen sizes.

      • Sometimes, elegance is in simplicity especially in the design.

        Info
        Category:
        Created:
        Updated:
        Featured Polls

        What is your preferred shape of #profile #pictures?  Please, elaborate on your choice in comments.

        Circle
         
        33 votes (56.9%)
        Square
         
        10 votes (17.24%)
        Rounded Square
         
        15 votes (25.86%)

        What kind of text #editor (if any) do you think should be used in a #Messenger?

        No editor, just plain text.
         
        20 votes (48.78%)
        Pure contentEditable standard browser tools.
         
        7 votes (17.07%)
        Pure Markdown or BBcode
         
        3 votes (7.32%)
        Editor based on contentEditable with WYSIWYG-style interface.
         
        7 votes (17.07%)
        WYSIWYG editor.
         
        4 votes (9.76%)

        Which method of #communication is most popular on your site?

        Discussions (asynchronous; public or group; committed subject).
         
        7 votes (17.95%)
        Conversations (asynchronous; private or group; variable subject).
         
        5 votes (12.82%)
        Messenger (synchronous or delayed; private, group or public; spontaneous or no subject).
         
        23 votes (58.97%)
        Comments (asynchronous; public; committed subject).
         
        4 votes (10.26%)